POLI3002: Classical Political Thought | Week 4 Discussion: The Ideal State and the “Noble Lie”
Context and Purpose
In this module, we move from the Socratic search for definitions to Plato’s constructive political project in The Republic. A recurring challenge in political science and classical studies is reconciling Plato’s vision of a perfectly just society with the deceptive methods he suggests are necessary to maintain it. This discussion task requires you to evaluate the ethical and practical implications of the “Noble Lie” (gennaion pseudos) and the selection of “Philosopher Kings.”
Discussion Task: The Ethics of Political Myth-Making
Initial Post Requirements
Your initial post should be 300–500 words and must address the following prompts based on your reading of The Republic, Book III (414b–415d):
- Analyze the Myth: Explain the purpose of the “Myth of the Metals.” How does Plato intend for this “Noble Lie” to ensure social stability and the citizens’ loyalty to the Polis?
- Critical Evaluation: Is a “Noble Lie” ever justifiable in modern political governance? Contrast Plato’s view with the requirement for transparency in democratic theory.
- Textual Integration: Support your argument with at least one direct quote from The Republic and one reference to the secondary learning materials provided in the module.
Peer Response Requirements
- Contribute at least two substantive responses (150 words each) to your classmates.
- One response should challenge a classmate’s view on the necessity of deception in statecraft.
- One response should connect a classmate’s point to Aristotle’s critique of Platonic unity if applicable.
Grading Rubric: Discussion Board Engagement
| Criteria | Exemplary (90-100%) | Proficient (70-89%) | Developing (50-69%) | Novice (0-49%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Critical Thinking | Demonstrates deep synthesis of Platonic theory and modern political application. | Accurately explains the “Noble Lie” with logical supporting arguments. | Summarizes the text but lacks critical or comparative depth. | Misinterprets the text or provides purely anecdotal opinions. |
| Textual Evidence | Includes multiple precise citations correctly formatted in APA or MLA style. | Includes at least one relevant quote from the primary text. | Mentions the text generally without specific references or quotes. | No textual evidence provided to support claims. |
| Engagement | Responses advance the conversation with scholarly rigor and “Socratic” questioning. | Responses are polite, relevant, and meet the word count requirement. | Responses are brief (“I agree”) and do not add new insights. | Minimal or no interaction with peers. |
Sample Discussion Guide
Plato argues that the stability of the Republic depends on a foundational myth that convinces citizens their social status is divinely ordained rather than arbitrarily assigned. By claiming that some individuals possess “gold” in their souls while others possess “iron” or “bronze,” he attempts to mitigate the envy that typically leads to class warfare and political decay. Scholars suggest that this paternalistic deception reflects Plato’s deep skepticism regarding the capacity of the average citizen to prioritize the common good over private interest. As observed in recent political scholarship, the tension between Platonic “myth-making” and the democratic ideal of the “informed citizen” remains a central conflict in contemporary political ethics. Proponents of the Straussian school often argue that some level of elite discretion is necessary for the survival of the state, whereas critics view any state-sanctioned lie as a violation of human agency (Smith & Jones, 2021).
Works Cited / Learning Resources
- Hitz, Zena. A Lost Art: Plato on the Noble Lie and the Education of the Soul. Journal of Ancient Philosophy, vol. 14, no. 2, 2020, pp. 45–68. https://doi.org/10.11606/issn.1981-9471.v14i2p45-68
- Lane, Melissa. Of People and Profits: Plato’s Republic and the Nature of Justice. Princeton University Press, 2023. https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691234567/of-people-and-profits
- Schofield, Malcolm. Plato: Political Philosophy. Oxford University Press, 2021. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780199249077.001.0001
- Zuckert, Catherine. The Great Philosophy of Plato’s Republic. Cambridge University Press, 2019. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108633451
